Sunday, July 5, 2020

Development of the Tragedy: The Wooden Horse, Keld Zeruneith -- First Note

During the Golden Age of Greece (450 - 400 BCE) two new forms of poetry were introduced: the dithyramb and tragic drama. Festivals included dithrambic choruses celebrating Greek heroes (as told by Homer and Hesiod); these choruses gradually evolved into one-man, two-man, and ultimately three-man tragedies. The tragedy was uniquely Athenian. The three great Athenian tragedians were Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Eripides. Aristotle wrote of the "ideal form" of tragedy. The myth became the centerpiece of these tragedies, but it was the presocratic philosophers who provided much of the inspiration for the tragedians. Over time, the tragedy became associated with the cult of Dionysos, and although this  might be a minor point in the overall history of the tragedy, it is important to understand the Dionysian background to fully understand the development of the tragedy.

This particular blog posting is a work in progress.  For me, this is really, really cool. I was always envious (if that is the right word) that my college freshman roommate memorized and loved Greek plays. If there is a gap in my education it is with Greek plays, Greek philosophers, physics and, in biology, the sponges and cnidarians. Smile.

So, this is really, really cool. For the first time I understand why Homer was so important; how Greek philosophers influenced Greek tragedy; how tragedy was born; how Greek philosophers influence Judeao-Christian beliefs. It is really incredible.

I remember, vaguely, reading a biography of Pericles when I might have been in eighth grade (about 14 years old). It was not assigned reading; I probably read it during the summer. I was fascinated by and in love with "adult" books from the "real" library, not the children's library, across the street from my middle school, which we called "Junior High."

These notes are for my own use, but who knows? Maybe they will stimulate someone else to read the book on which most of this posting is based. Many of the full sentences and long passages are direclty from the book, so don't use these notes for your essays without citing the author (Keld Zeruneith).

I am using Keld Zeruneith's The Wooden Horse to put together my understanding of the development of the tragedy.

 History

Golden Age of Greece: 448 BCE to 404 BCE
448 BCE: end of the Persian Wars
429 BCE death of Pericles
404 BCE: end of the Peloponnesian War
Four tribes made up Classical Greece during the Golden age: Dorians, Ionians, Aeolians, and Aeachians
Peisistratus: c. 590 - 527
Tyrant: popular. (tyrant: a single ruler with a non-heritable position; taken entirely by personal ability often in violation of tradition or constitutional norms)
Instituted the Panathenaic Festival
First attempt to produce a definitive version of the Homeric epics
Tried to distribute power and benefits
Four tribes --> ten demes; abolished surnames
The elites, who held power in the Areopagus Council, were allowed to keep their archonships
Under his rule, two new forms of poetry introduced: dithyramb and tragic drama
Saw the growth of the theater, arts and sculpture
Commissioned the permanent copying and archiving of Homer's two epic poems
The canon of Homeric works said to derive from the particular archiving
Son, Hippias, ruled like his father, but paranoid and oppressive after murder plot against his brother

Cleisthenes: c. 500 - 470
Helped establish a democracy based on the overturned reforms of Solon
Expanded the four traditional tribes (based on family names) into ten tribes based on geographical location; abolished surnames; referred to be their demes (area of residence)
Estimated to have 139 demes (areas of residence)
True democracy principles put in place (legislators chosen by lottery)
Introduced ostracism
Disappears from history shortly after instituting these reforms: ostracized?
Greek Poets and Presocratic Philosophers

Homer:700 BCE, aristocratic, heroic values

Hesiod: 700 BCE, agrarian values, possible a cousin of Homer's
Competed at Euboea
Theogeny: catalogue of the gods
Works and Days: poetry begins in earnest to express experience on a subjective basis

Archilochus: 650 BCE, warrior poet
Born on island of Paros
Would not risk his life for external honor

Sappho: 612 BCE, the "10th muse"
Contemporary of Alkaeus, also of Lesbos
Among females, the equal of Homer
10 books
Like Archilochus: follows her passion; that's why she liked Helen
Created a special metrical unit: the so-called Sapphic strophe

Thales: 600 BCE, born in Egypt
Beginning of natural philosophy
Attempts to create comprehensible and at least partially exhaustive cosmology
If he did study in Egypt, explains Presocratic philosophy
Presocratic philosophy did not spring out of thin air -- preceded by Oriental philosophy
For Thales: water -- the fundamental material of creation

Anaximander: 619 - 545 BCE (dying at age 64)
The primary exponent for breakout out of an entire new / exact world of science
Prose: first to write his book in prose!
Rejected the notion that water was fundamental material of creation
Replaced it with aperion (beginning); ~ arche -- beginning (p. 314)
Xenophanes: b. 570 BCE; Colophon, Asia Minor
Founded important school of philosophy at Elea, southern Italy
Represents an essential step forward toward the recognition of the meaning of inner experience of the world
Rejected the anthropomorphic conception of the gods

Heraclitus: b. 545; Ephesus, Ionia (born the year Anaximander died)
Zeld's favorite philosopher of this group
May have been a student of Xanaphanes
Develops his own quite personal philosophical ideas
Heir to royalty; gave it to his brother
Considered obscure
Lived away from the city to ensure "his own" ideas
"Like a disciple of Jesus or the Gnostics, the individual seeking insight must break away from his parents, i.e., from the entrenched prejudice of tradition." (p. 317)
An elitist
Logos: developed by Heraclius; the insight the wise man acquires by virtue of his own inner conscious order
Disliked Homer, Hesiod, also his slightly oder contemporary: Pythagoras
They (Pythagoras/Heraclitus) differed on their vision of the soul (p. 323)

Parmenides: b. 515 BCE
May have been a student of Xenophanes (like Heraclius)
May have conversed with the younger Socrates (as Plato says)
Argues the opposite of Xenophanes
Argues that the external, objective world is illusory
His philosophy written in hexameter poem
Denies the reality of the senses
Empedocles: b. 400 BCE
Compiler and epitomizer
Rhetorician, physician, philospher
Admired and closely connected to Parmenides
First to put together the four basic elements: water, air, fire
Thales: water
Heraclitus: fire
Anaximenes: air
Empedocles: earth
Empedocles: these form the causes of the world's beginning
Two basic driving forces: love and strife
Anthropomorphizes these forces as Aphrodite and Ares
Mythical thinking still had hold on these philosophers
Cyclical: love and strife
Inspiration may have come form Pythagoras

[Pythagoras: b. 570; Ionian, Samos Island]

Tragedy

"Athens greatest contribution to world literature was surely to bring tragedy to perfection."

"A new genre will arise from an existential and social need at a given historical point to work through and interpret existing reality."  [A new genre arises when a need arises to work through/interpret existing reality.]

But even Aristotle, who lived about 150 year after the development of the tragedy, was uncertainty that surrounded the rise of the epic.

Originally short stories, satire. Then, the return of the epic, a centrifying mythical plot, with music and dance, an integral choreographic and dramatic constituent element.

Tragedy:
  • Form: developed from the Dionysian dithyramb
  • Content: derived from myth, especially Homer's
Comedy: from komai ("outlying hamlet") Outlying hamlets were called demes, according to Aristotle.

Incredibly: Aristotle does not mention Arion, the 7th century poet who first imbued the dithyrambic choruses with the character of the tragedy

Tragedy: a remarkable return to myth

The Dorians in the Peloponnesus originated the tragedy. The Dorians were one of four Greek tribes at this time The other Greek tribes were the Ionians (Crete, Asia Minor), Archaeans (along with the Danaas, the two oldest Greek tribes), and Aeolians (Thessaly; most powerful and numerous).
Herodotus: the first dithyrambic chorus was first arranged by the tyrant Periandros in Corinth,while the connection with the cult of Dionysos arose when the tyrant of Sicyon transferred the tragic chorus of the hero cult to the worship of Dionysos. In Athens, tradition has it that the first names tragedian Thespis won a prize for tragedy (~ 534 BCE) under Peisistratos.
Socrates: "Homer seems to have been the first teacher and beginner of all these beauties of tragedy"

The genres of epic and tragedy connect with each other beneath all other forms of literature that had arisen in the meantime.

Homer, epic: sought to convert aristocratic and heroic ideals into peaceful values

Myth redivivus (the tragedy): sought to formulate a new set of rules for democratic citizens of Athens.

The philosophers above had tried to tone down the mythical and the heroic -- now the tragedians returned to myth and the heroic age.

Now: competitions among tragedies were held in the honor of the deity of the Great Dionysia in Athens!

Another connects Dionysia with birth of tragedy.

Improvisation.

Comedy: originated with phallic songs.

Tragedy: originated with the authors of the dithyramb
Dithyramb: formed part of the essence of the genre

Dithyramb: connected with the birth of Dionysos -- indirectly makes it a song of birth and initiation.

See Euripedes, The Bacchae, Dionysos, dithyramb -- p. 330 (Greek, Bacchus; Latin, Dionysos)

Tragedy seriously began to develop as an independent genre on the basis of the dithyrambic choral  lyric during the role of the tyrant Peisistratos, who along with the Eleusinian Mysteries, incorporated Dionysos into the religious life of the state. In this way, he could accommodate the general public's worship of the god and bring the Dionysian intoxication, which washed over Hellas like a wave, under control. See p. 331 for birth of tragedy under Peisistratos.

Euripedes' The Bacchae: the only extant tragedy about Dionysos and his distinctive features.

Dionysos: byname of Dithyrambos due to myth that he was born twice -- by his mother Semele, a Theban princess, and his father Zeus. Myth has it that Hera tricked Zeus into launching a lightning bolt that killed Semele, but not before Dionysos was safety delivered.

The Tragedians

Aeschylus: sets the foundation
Shapes tragedy and establishes the norms around sophrosyne and piety necessary for citizens to display
Action and reflection not clearly separated
Credited with introducing a second actor
Some say he also introduced the third actor, but Aristotle says he took that from Eripides
Trilogies; the other two did away with trilogies; too much like epics, ponderous
The Persians: oldest play that has survived; based on Athens victory over Persia's Xerxes, Salamis
Oresteia

Sophocles: the poet of piety
Oedipus: becomes psychologically conscious of his identity through an unraveling of his earlier history. But, man was still powerless before the gods.
Oedipus Rex: said to come closest to the ideal, according to Aristotle
Oedipus Rex: tragedy par excellence

Euripides: the poet of negative values
Reveals the consequences of the dissolution of the state for human life with a deep-seated longing for resolution
Questioned the very existence and justice of the gods
Introduced the third actor, according to Aristotle

As a triad: these three great tragedians come to represent distinctive stages of consciousness during this period.

Redisovering Homer: Inside The Origins Of The Epic, Andrew Dalby, c. 2006

I am re-reading Rediscovering Homer: Inside the Origins of the Epic, by Andrew Dalby, c. 2006. So often, I find reading a book the second time through is so much more rewarding. I already know the thesis, the ending, the viewpoint of the author. Now, I can go back and see how the author developed the story.

I am always amazed how little information about the Trojan War is actually in the Iliad. The poem only covers the last few weeks near the end of the ten-year siege/war and does NOT include the tale of the Trojan Horse. That little detail and much of the rest of what we know about the war is found in the Odyssey. 

 The hero of the Iliad is Achilles, but interestingly is not called by that name or even references him in the title. Hold that thought.

The author also notes that the Iliad and the Odyssey are two of the very, very few surviving pieces of literature from that period. Hold that thought.

"Homer" was the singer/poet who is credited with the two epics. But "Homer" did not write down the epics; that was done by someone else, probably around 650 BC. "Homer" himself lived two to four hundred years earlier.

Early on, Andrew Dalby asks the question: why did someone write down the two long poems. I think he answered his own question in the introduction. It will be interesting to see how he develops his answer. I've forgotten, so I'm looking forward to rereading the book.

Dalby notes that a new temple was built for Athene at the time the Iliad and the Odyssey were written. It took years, of course, to plan, build, and consecrate the new temple for Athene, and I am convinced that the Iliad and the Odyssey were commissioned to accompany the "grand opening."

The hero of the Iliad and the Odyssey was not Achilles. The hero(ine) was Athene. She saved Achilles and she saved the Achaean/Mycenaean Greeks. Just as their are many mortal "heroes" in the Bible, the Bible is a story about God/Jesus, the Homeric epics have many mortal "heroes" but the epics, in the end, are about Athene.

I have never had the interest in reading the Iliad but in this new light, that might be worthwhile. 

Random Note On The Iliad And The Odyssey

Andrew Dalby will opine that The Iliad and The Odyssey were most likely written down by a woman.

I happened to re-read this post regarding Keld Zeruneith's The Wooden Horse:

Odysseus does not get his cunning from strangers. Its genetic source can, as we heard, be traced back to his grandfather Autolykos ("the wolf himself"). It has the result that he is always the subject of suspicion and hatred, even among his own in the Iliad.

Seen from the viewpoint of the heroic, it is impossible not to think precisely of the feminine in relation to cunning and the negative assessment of it. It is said that female cunning is the strongest weapon in the world. And the two female characters who are supremely skilful at employing this strategy are Penelope, who uses cunning to keep her husband, and Klytemnestra, who does the same to kill hers. Women use cunning for at least two reasons. First, because they do not have a man's physique. Secondly, their insight is based on the fact that they are not at one with the male world of action. They can contemplate it from without and then devise their schemes in relation to the motives that make a man act more or less consciously -- especially the latter. In this way, Klytemnestra in the Orestia can manipulate Agamemnon through his vanity to his death.  
I will have to go back and read both books. I will start with The Wooden Horse.

******************

I first talked about this in a note to my granddaughters:  I am absolutely convinced The Iliad and The Odyssey were written (down) under the editorship of a woman, and that the two-volume epic was to be the Greek Bible to be placed in Athene's/Athena's temple. Dalby's book first suggested this; re-reading Zeruneith's book supports this view.

The Greek Myths: Stories Of The Greek Gods And Heroes Vividly Retold, Robin Wakefield And Kathryn Wakefield, c. 2011

Chapter 1
Hope for Mankind
The population of the earth

Chapter 2
The Ascent of the Olympian Gods
In the beginning
War against the Titans
War against the Giants
Zeus and his brothers

Chapter 3
The Gods of Olympus
Zeus the king
Hera
Hestia
Demeter
Aphrodite
Ares
Hephaestus
Athena
Apollo
Artemis
Hermes
Dionysus

Chapter  4
The Age of Heroes
The flood
The line of Deucalion
The Argonauts and the Golden Fleece
The Calydonian Boar Hunt
Io and the Daniads
Perseus adn the Gorgon
Bellerophon

Chapter 5
Thebes in the Age of Heroes
Cadmus, Europa, and the Foundation of Thebes
Oedipus
The seven against Thebes

Chapter 6
Mycenae in the Age of Heroes
The curse of the House of Atreus
Atreus and Thyestes
The end of the Atreid curse

Chapter 7
Athens in the Age of Heroes
The first Athenian kings
The Labours of Theseus
Theseus and the Minotaur
King Theseus

Chapter 8
Heracles
The birth of Heracles
The twelve labours of Hercules
Heracles the king-maker
Heracles becomes a god

Chapter 9
The Trojan War
The marriage of Peleus and Thetis
The judgement of Paris
The Abduction of Helen
The Greeks prepare for war
The Greek landing
Achilles withdraws
Agamemnon's dream
Menelaus and Paris
Diomedes' day of glory
Hector triumphant
Envoys and spies
The Assault on the ships
The deception of Zeus
The death of Patrochus
The return of Achilles
The death of Hector
Two funerals
The death of Achilles
The wooden horse
The fall of Troy

Chapter 10
Odysseus' Return
Trouble on Ithaca
Telemachs' journey
Odysseus on Scheria
The Cyclops Polphemus
Aeolus, the Laestrygonians, and Circe
The underworld
Dangers at sea
The cattle of the sun
Odysseus reaches Ithaca
At the swineherd's hut
In the palace
Penelope meets the beggar
Vengeance
Reuninon

Chapter 11
Pandora



*************************************
Odysseus on Scheria

Island of Scheria
  • Phaeacians
  • King Alcinous
  • Queen Arete
  • Nausicaa, the royal princess
Odysseus ally: Athene
  • disguised herself as a childhood companion and convinced Nausicaa to go to the river (where Odysseus was)
Odysseus: arrives at the island of Scheria home of the Phaeacians and the last destination of Odysseus in his 10-year journey before returning home to Ithaca.

Ithaca: one of the seven Ionian islands; off the west coast of Greece; midway between northernmost island and southernmost island.

He had just spent seven years as a captive of Calypso.

Scheria: most likely, Corfu
  • within 68 miles of Ithaca
  • Thucydides: Corcyra, in Peloponnesian War
Phaeacians did not participate in the Trojan War.

The Phaeacians in the Odyssey did not know Odysseus (although they knew of him, as evidenced by the tales of Demodocus), so they called him a "stranger."

Odysseus however was the king of the majority of the Ionian Islands, not only of Ithaca, but also of Cephallenia, Neritum, Crocylea, Aegilips, Same and Zacynthus so if Scheria was Corfu, it would be surprising that the citizens of one of the Ionian Islands did not know Odysseus.

Kerkyra: Greek isle also known as Corfu in English; Kerkyra is just off shore Greece, and very, very close to Ithaca.

Some suggest Scheria was Crete.

From wiki, the seven islands:
  • Kerkyra (Corfu in English)
  • Paxi (Paxos)
  • Lefkada (Lefkas)
  • Ithaki (Ithaca)
  • Kefalonia (Cefalonia)
  • Zakynthos (Zante)
  • Kythira (Cythera) -- southernmost; off the tip of the Peloponnese; not part of the region of the Ionian Islands; included in the region of Attica.
The Ionian Islands: the Ionian Islands are a group of islands in Greece; west side of Greece, in the Ionian Sea, except for Kythera, at the southern tip of the Peloponnese. They are traditionally called the Heptanese ("Seven Islands") but the group includes many smaller islands as well as the seven principal ones.

Not related to Ionia, an Anatolian region.

As a distinct historic region they date to the centuries-long Venetian rule, which preserved them from becoming part of the Ottoman Empire, and created a distinct cultural identity with many Italian influences. The Ionian Islands became part of the modern Greek state in 1864. Administratively today they belong to the Ionian Islands Region except for Kythera, which belongs to the Attica Region.

Nausicaa leads Odysseus to the royal palace.

King Alcinous agrees to outfit a ship to get Odysseus back to Ithaca.

Key point: the bard at the palace of Alcinous, Demodocus, told the story of the wooden horse, and also stated that the plan was hatched by Odysseus.

Odysseus then tells King Alcinous of his past.
  • the cyclops Polyphemus
  • Aeolus, the Laestrygoians, and Circe
  • the Underworld
  • dangers at sea
Finally, page 288: Odysseus reaches Ithaca.

Apparently they disembarked / set sail / "cast off with the chariot of the sun descending in the west."

"While it was still dark, they reached Ithaca and beached in a remote cove."

Barely a night's journey.

***************************************
Io

Ionian Sea: named for Io, who swam across the Ionian sea, from Greece to Italy

Athens: in the care of Athene
Argos: in the care of Hera; known for its horses and cattle

Father: Inachus, first king of Argos, after whom the Inachus River was named; most ancient god or hero of Argos; one of the river gods, all sons of Titans Oceanus and Tethys, part of the pre-Olympian or "Pelasgian" myths.
Io: born from Inachus alone;
Wife of Inachus as time Io was born, also his sister: Oceanid nymph Melia, daughter of Oceanus

Zeus / Io
transforms Io into a heifer to deceive Hera
Hera asks for the heifer which Zeus gives her
Hera sends 100-eyed Argus Panoptes to watch / protect Io from Zeus
Zeus sends Hermes, who slays Argus

Hera sends a gadfly to continuously sting Io
Io eventually crosses the path between the Propontis and the Black Sea; Bosporus (ox passage)
Io meet Prometheus; had been chained on Mt Caucasus by Zeus
Prometheus tells Io that she will eventually regain human form; become ancestress of the greatest of all heroes, Heracles

Io escapes across the Ionian Sea to Egypt
restored to human form by Zeus
gives birth to Zeus' son Epaphus and a daughter, Keroessa

Io marries Egyptian king Telegonus
their grandson Danaus eventually returned to Greece with his 50 daughters, the Danaids), as recalled in Aeschylus' play, The Suppliants

Io connected with the moon by the ancients
in Aeschylus' Prometheus Bound, where Io encounters Prometheus, she refers to herself as the "horned virgin"

Seven Against Thebes, Third Of The Theban Trilogy -- June 27, 2020

Geography:
  • Thessaly (Aeolia): northeastern Greece 
  • Boeotia: sits between Aeolia (Thessaly) and Attica
  • Attica: southeastern Greece; end of the Greek peninsula coming down from rest of Europe: Thebes, Athens;
  • Peloponnesia: to the southwest of rest of mainland Greece; became an island with canal across Corinth cut; Argos just on the other side of the canal (in Peloponnese); Sparta
Thebes: about an hour north of Athens on modern roads.
  • a city in Boeotia: one of the regional units of Greece
  • part of the region of Central Greece
  • capital is Livadeia, but the largest city is Thebes
  • Boeotia, southwest of Thessaly, was known as Aeolia 
  • Boeotians may have been related to Thessaly
  • said to have been dispossessed by the northwestern Thessalians two generations after the fall of Troy
Thebes: why it's important
  • played an important role in Greek myths
  • site of stories of Cadmus, Oedipus, Dionysis, Heracles, others
  • clay tablets, Linear B script -- Bronze Age
  • remember: fall of Troy: end of the Bronze Age
  • largest city of the ancient region of Boeotia; leader of the Boeotian confederacy
  • a major rival of Athens
  • sided with the Persians during the 480 BC invasion under Xerxes
  • Theban forces ended the power of Sparta, 371 BC
  • elite Sacred Band of Thebes fell against Philip II and Alexander the Great, 335 BC
Diomedes:
  • a hero in Greek mythology for role in Trojan War
  • Iliad: Achilles at the top warrior, but the next three:
    • Ajax the Great; Agamemnon; and Diomedes
    • these three: the Aecheans want one of these three to fight Hector out of nine volunteers (included Odysseus and Ajax the Lesser)
    • note: Jason and the Argonauts, Golden Fleece: about 1300 BC; before the Trojan War;
  • Argos: Peloponnese
  • maternal grandfather: Adrastus -- legendary king of Argos during the wars of the Seven Against Thebes
  • parents: Tydeus (Aetolian) and Deipyle (Argive -- resident of Argos)
  • Diomedes: becomes king of Argos following his maternal grandfather, Adrastus
  • founded ten Italian cities
  • after his death, worshipped as a god by both Greeks and Romans
Background:
  • Tydeus expelled from his homeland, Thebes
  • found refuge with his maternal grandfather, the king of Argos
  • Argos agreed to help; gathered an expeditionary force to march against Thebes
  • this force made up up seven individual champions, each assigned to lead an assalt on one of the seven gates of the city
  • Tydeus, Polynices and Adrastus were among them
  • sort of foreshadowing the Trojan War
  • these seven known as the "Seven Against Thebes"
  • disastrous; all seven slain except King Adrastus, escaped on his fast horse Arion
  • Tydeus was slain
  • Diomedes was four years old when his dad was killed -- so, if Diomedes fought in the Trojan War, "seven against Thebes" occurred before the Trojan War;
  • the sons of the seven fallen vowed to vanquish Thebes in order to avenge their father; called the Epigoni -- they were born after everything has happened
  • ten years later they march on Thebes
  • the war of the Epigoni is remembered as the most important expedition in Greek mythology before the Trojan War
  • a favorite topic for epics but all those epics have been lost
  • the son of King Adrastus was killed in this battle; the only male heir left was Diomedes
  • Diomedes made king; in order to secure the throne, he married the daughter of his brother princes Aegialia
  • so, Diomedes was king of Argos
Now switching gears:
  • Diomedes paternal grandfather, Oeneus put in jail -- Calydonian politics; Caldon, homeland of Tydeus
Now, back to Tydeus:
  • an Aeolian hero of the generation before the Trojan War
    • Aeolian (Thessaly): northeast mainland Greece; northeast of Athens
  • one of the seven against Thebes
  • father of Diomedes, frequently known by the patronymic Tydides
  • Tydeus: parents were Oeneus and either Periboea or Oeneus's daughter (incest)
  • Tydeus: husband of Deipyle, the mother of Diomedes
  • Adrastus, king of Argos
  • housed Tydeus, who married daughter of Adrastus
  • also housed Polynices (led the seven against Thebes)
  • exiled son of Oedipus who had shared the rule of Thebes with brother Eteocles
  • Tydeus and Polynices got into a brawl
  • Tydeus (boar) and Polynices (lion)
  • Adrastus wed his daughters to those two men
  • so ultimately, Diomedes becomes king of Argos and heirs of Polynices are restored to Thebes

***************************
Aeschylus
Seven Against Thebes

Zeld, p. 351:
"Considering how few of Aeschylus' tragedies have survived, it is amazing that in The Frogs Aristophanes mentions both The Persians and Seven Against Thebes, from five years earlier, as examples of military bravado. Aeschylus replies that they were written in praise of Ares -- that is to say a sort of mobilization-text intended to around the spectators' "spirit of war" and the desire to fight the enemy by showing what heroic courage is."
Greeks defeat the Persians:
  • Greeks: moderating
  • Persians: defeated by their own hubris
Thebes: setting for the story of Oedipus.

Oedipus was brother of Polynices; the latter led the seven against Thebes; all seven died except King Andrastus
  • if I understand the genealogy, Oedipus impregnated his mother Jacosta: Polynices was one of the four offspring from that incestuous relationship
    • mother Jacosta
    • sons (and brothers) Oedipus and Polynices
    • father and son: Oedipus (father) and Polynices (son)
    • father and brother: Oedipus
    • mother and wife: Jacosta
The trilogy, referred to as the Oedipodea:
  • Laius (no long extant)
  • Oedipus (no long extant)
  • Seven Against Thebes (only one of the three that survives)
The trilogy won first prize at Dionysia.

Three generations, beginning with King Laios, through Oedipus, and the children of Oedipus and his wife/mother:
Oedipus solved the riddle, and the Sphinx killed herself. In reward, he received the throne of Thebes and the hand of the widowed queen, his mother, Jocasta. They had four children: Eteocles, Polyneices, Antigone, and Ismene.
 

***********************
Sophocles
Three Theban Plays

See "the three tragedians."

Sophocles "three Theban plays":
  • Oedipus Rex
  • Oedipus at Colonus
  • Antigone
Parents -- King Laios and Queen Jacosta: Thebes


Oedipus:
  • daughter: Antigone was his guide after he blinded himself
  • sons: Eteocles and Polynices, sharing the kingdom; ultimately leads to seven against Theses
  • both Eteolcles and Polynices are killed (killed each other)
  • a third brother, Creon, took the throne
  • conflict between Antigone and Creon (different stories by Sophocles and Euripides
Apparently all three great Greek tragedians wrote about this story.
  • Sophocles, already mentioned
  • in Euripides' plays on the subject; Jocasta did not kill herself
  • the blinding of Oedipus does not appear in sources earlier than Aeschylus

The Wooden Horse , Keld Zeruneith -- Early Notes -- Re-Posting -- May 31, 2020

This note was originally posted April 3, 2010, but for some reason it linked to Amazon. So I'm re-posting it here so I can link it properly.

The three tragedians: Aeschylus (the old man), Sophocles (the rock star), and Euripides (a rebel, controversial, born in 480 BC). After Euripides, there were no more tragedians of note. Following these three tragedians came the three philosophers: Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle (the first scientist).

Important dates:

  • Homer probably lived around 650 BC
  • Athenians defeat the Persians: 480 BC 
  • Golden era of Greece: 5th century BC; under leadership of Pericles, 495 - 429 BC; 15 years old when Athenians crushed the Persians
  • Tragedy: during the 50-year golden era of Greece, following the defeat of the Persians
  • Aeschylus: 525 - 455 BC -- about 80 years old when he died; middle-aged/older when Persians defeated
  • Sophocles: 496 - 406 BC -- about 16 years old when Athenians defeated the Persians; 90 years old
  • Euripides: 480 - 406 BC -- 74 years old; born the same year the Athenians defeat the Persians
  • Socrates: 470 - 399 BC -- overlapped with Euripides; ten years younger than Euripides
    Plato: 428 - 348 BC -- lived to be 76 years old
  • Aristotle: 384 - 322 BC -- lived to be 62 years old
  • Alexander the Great: 356 - 323 BC; a contemporary of Aristotle
  • Caesar Augustus: founder of the Roman Empire; its first emperor, 63 BC - 14 AD
Note: Pericles was the son of the politician Xanthippus, who, though ostracized in 485 - 484 BC, returned to Athens to command the Athenian contingent in the Greek victory at Mycale just five years later. Mycale was one of the two major battles that ended the second Persian invasion of Greece during the Greco-Persian Wars, late August, 479 BC, on the slopes of Mount Mycale, on the coast of Ionia, opposite the island of Samos. Xerxes I led the Persians. Xerxes had taken much of Greece earlier, but at the ensuing Battle of Salamis, Greece won an unlikely victory, and therefore prevented the conquest of the Peloponnese. The Peloponnese is the peninsula, southern Greece, separated from northern Greece by the Gulf of Corinth. 

This might be the best book for someone well versed in Greek mythology and Greek tragedy to use as a reference book for all of this.

The framework for all this:
  • the Bible, probably first writings, about 1400 BC; oral history back to 3000 BC
  • the poet Homer probably lived around 650 BC
  • tragedy "born" in Greece, the 50-year golden era of Greece, following defeat of Persians in 480 BC; tragedians trying to move away from Homer
  • three Greek tragedians all you really need to know: Aeschylus (the old man), Sophocles (the rock star), and Euripides (a rebel, controversial, born in 480 BC)
  • the three philosopher/scientists followed: Socrates (the philosopher who never wrote down anything); Plato (the student of Socrates; pretty much impossible to separate the philosophy of Socrates from Plato, but easy to separate the men); Aristotle (the first scientist)
The tragedians:
  • Aeschylus: Oresteia -- the "tragedy above all other tragedies"; trilogy, second actor, and possibly the third actor, though Sophocles is given credit for the third actor; Oresteia Aeschylus' view of life
  • Sophocles: abandoned the trilogy; focused on a single actor as the protagonist; Ajax (one of Sophocles' oldest surviving tragedies); Antigone (written about the same time; much more gruesome than Ajax; Oedipus the King (wrote two plays of Oedipus including just before his death at age 90); Oedipus was Sophocles' view of life, just as Oresteia was for Aeschylus; "Sophocles was unable to let Oedipus go, wanting to demonstrate explicitly that it was meaningful and, above all, an example of how grandly the gods can view a man's destiny, since they finally sanctify Oedipus."
  • Euripides: won very few prizes (as opposed to Aeschylus and Sophocles); a rebel; "his main characters display hitherto unseen passions, and dramatically peripheral or useless figures such as peasants appear on stage and are credited with a noble quality that the traditional heroic types lack in their arrogance. In addition, the gods seem to be deranged and Fate irresistible and unavoidable, while love leads to destruction. Women seem to be hated and men pathetic in their oppression." -- p. 456, Zeruneith. Iphigenia at Aulis; Electra; Orestes; Iphigenia at Taurus; Medea; Hippolytos; The Bacchae
After Sophocles and Euripides, it appears tragedy was dead because there were no good tragedians.

Did we have to wait almost 2,000 years for Shakespeare to appear?

 ******************************

Those who want even more of Homer and the Iliad and the Odyssey, I heartily recommend The Wooden Horse by Keld Zeruneith. This is a phenomenal book, copyright 2007; I just happened to run across it at the local discount book store.

I know very little about this Danish author, but it would be hard to imagine someone, anyone, knowing more about Greek mythology, Homer, Hesiod, the Greek tragedians, or the Greek philosophers, than Zeruneith.

His 1970 master's thesis was titled, "The Odyssey Motif in Homer, Virgil, Dante and Joyce."

Some years ago I was in my James Joyce phase and read his Ulysses. In order to attack Ulysses, I had to to a lot of background reading, and even now, I assume I understand less than one percent of Ulysses and probably even less of Homer's duad.

One of the nice things about The Wooden Horse is that once you have read the foreword and the first chapter or so, you can feel comfortable skipping around. The author states at the outset that the book has a "comprehensive conceptual sequence" but the chapters tend to stand alone. It is important to read the first couple chapters in sequence since the author introduces concepts and Greek words that he will dwell on throughout this very, very scholarly study.

It is impossible for me to articulate everything the author has to say, but here is just one passage that should pique your interest:
Odysseus does not get his cunning from strangers. Its genetic source can, as we heard, be traced back to his grandfather Autolykos ("the wolf himself"). It has the result that he is always the subject of suspicion and hatred, even among his own in the Iliad.

Seen from the viewpoint of the heroic, it is impossible not to think precisely of the feminine in relation to cunning and the negative assessment of it. It is said that female cunning is the strongest weapon in the world. And the two female characters who are supremely skillful at employing this strategy are Penelope, who uses cunning to keep her husband, and Klytemnestra, who does the same to kill hers. Women use cunning for at least two reasons. First, because they do not have a man's physique. Secondly, their insight is based on the fact that they are not at one with the male world of action. They can contemplate it from without and then devise their schemes in relation to the motives that make a man act more or less consciously -- especially the latter. In this way, Klytemnestra in the Orestia can manipulate Agamemnon through his vanity to his death.
Plan to be stranded on a South Pacific island this summer? Take a copy of Homer's Iliad and Odyssey; Keld Zeruneith's The Wooden Horse; James Joyce's Ulysses; and, Gifford's Ulysses Annotated.

Discursivity: Philosophy. Chiefly with reference to the philosophy of Kant: the quality of reasoning by a series of logical steps.

Discursive democracy = deliberative democracy. Compare with "direct democracy."

**************************

Chapter I: The Wooden Horse -- The Myth of Discursivity

1. In The Iliad, XV, 71: Homer buries a line, stating that the 10-year siege has been a waste of time. Heroics have not worked; time for strategy, cunning, wiliness; sets the stage in The Iliad for Odysseus. Athena/Athene is the heroine, working through a mortal. The line in XV, 71:
Troy will fall through the designs of Athene.
2. Other references to Odysseus and his wiliness, metis.

3. A bit of background to the wooden horse:
  • Troy can only fall with Herakles' bow
  • the bow was made by Herakles but given to Philoktetes who lit Herakles' funeral pyre
  • Odysseus had abandoned Philoktetes on Lemnos due to the latter's "putrid" wounds
  • Odysseus, Diomedes, and Neoptolemos all go back to rescue Philoktetes; cured
  • Philoktetes shoots/kills Prince Paris, who earlier killed Achilles (arrow to his vulnerable heel)
Also, the seer Kalchas says that the Trojan prophet, Helenos (note: named after Helen), the son of Helen and Paris, must be captured and forced to tell the Greeks how Troy can be taken
4. The story of the wooden horse, from architect's design, to entering the city, killing all Trojans, except Aeneas, who escapes with a group of fugitives to become the founder of Rome.

5. The heroic age (Achilles) is thus over; a new age (Odysseus) has begun. The form of consciousness that lay behind the Wooden Horse -- dolos (guile) and metis (shrewdness) represent a watershed in the formation of his (Odysseus') identity.

6. Odysseus: proud to proclaim himself as "the sacker of cities." Agnomen. One of the most commonly used words, polymetis is used 66 times in Odysseus and is also used in The Iliad. The author says no good translation of polymetis: what about "polymath"? Metis was born of Oceanus and Tethys, of an earlier age than Zeus and his siblings.  
Metis was the first great spouse of Zeus. Athene/Athena was the daughter of Metis/Zeus. Thus, the author argues, "polymetis" is has a lineage to Athene/Athena through her mother Metis.
7. "In short, in iconographical terms the Wooden Horse signifies a shift in civilization." The mythical heroic world is overturned.
Might one consider "the Wooden Horse" a metonym for strategic thinking? "To solve this problem, we need a "wooden horse."" A "wooden horse" is more specific than simply "strategic thinking.
8. Sophrosyne. "More particularly, what happens is that Odysseus, by virtue of his metis, is able to act discursively (multiple meanings for discursive: rambling; or moving coherently from topic to topic, contemplative, thinking rationally, considering options). Odysseus able to control his emotions; able to move from mythic heroic world to civilized, intellectual thinking.

First use of sophrosyne: "So this enables Odysseus to exercise a self-control that is peculiar to him and the first example of the composure that later becomes a fundamental value in Greek thinking known as sophrosyne.

9. "... an understanding of and ability to adapt and control his inner impulses."

10. "On an individual level, Odysseus finally becomes the person he truly is by virtue of the Wooden Horse." He is the original "transformer." A nice summary of this chapter, pp 30 - 31. One almost gets the feeling that the author Keld Zeruneith is taking the baton from the aging Harold Bloom in looking "where wisdom is found."

From wiki:
In Greek mythology, Autolycus (Ancient Greek: Αὐτόλυκος, Autolykos, "The Wolf Itself") was a son of the Olympian god Hermes and Chione. He was the husband of Neaera, or according to Homer, of Amphithea. Autolycus fathered Anticlea (who married Laertes of Ithaca and was the mother of Odysseus) and several sons, of whom only Aesimus is named.
Odysseus is the grandson of the god, Hermes.
 
"Odysseus has inherited this ambiguity from his grandfather Autolykos, a son of the god Hermes, renowned for his cunning and thievish ways. The close relationship to Hermes is also revealing, because not only was he the god of thieves but also the god of transformation and interpretation -- hermeneutics."
[Hermeneutics: The early usage of "hermeneutics" places it within the boundaries of the sacred. A divine message must be received with implicit uncertainty regarding its truth. This ambiguity is an irrationality; it is a sort of madness that is inflicted upon the receiver of the message. Only one who possesses a rational method of interpretation (i.e., a hermeneutic) could determine the truth or falsity of the message.
Folk etymology places its origin with Hermes, the mythological Greek deity who was the 'messenger of the gods'. Besides being a mediator between the gods and between the gods and men, he led souls to the underworld upon death. Hermes was also considered to be the inventor of language and speech, an interpreter, a liar, a thief, and a trickster.
These multiple roles made Hermes an ideal representative figure for hermeneutics.]
Chapter II: The Homeric Project
The Myth and Metaphor of "Homer"

1. The historical Homer. Most likely lived around 650 B.C.

2. Homer's ancestry: through one story, Homer would be the grandchild of Odysseus (and Odysseus was the grandson of Hermes through his mother). [Note: the author uses the word "grandchild," not "grandson" or "granddaughter."
From Delphi, for example, for example, comes the following answer: "Ithaka is his country, Telemachos his father, Iokaste, Nestor's daughter, his mother." That is to say Homer was supposed to have been the fruit of a possible love relationship between Telemachos and Polykaste, Nestor's daughter, whom he meets on his voyage. In that case, Homer would be the grandchild of Odysseus!
Nestor was 110 years old when he fought with the Greeks in the Trojan war; so his daughter married Telemachos, the son of Odysseus.  

3. The author will dispense with this train of thought, and will take a radically different approach. The author will use the name Homer as a metaphor for the narrator's activity of linking or binding things together: of composing. "The challenge is to find the guiding principle behind the Homeric project that can put the works into a coherent experience and understanding." -- p. 34

4. The importance of Zeus, the "fulfiller of life."

5. "As the beginning of the Iliad has it, the will of Zeus is accomplished, though not completely until and with the end of the Odyssey. Although, at the Iliad's narrative level, it is a matter of restoring Achilleus' honor, this does not preclude that, in a more general sense, it is a question of ending the war."

"Insofar as it is the intent of both Zeus and Homer to guide the specific themes -- wrath and homecoming -- through the Iliad and the Odyssey, it may also be concluded that as a metaphorical entity Homer merges with the divine telos and does so in the composite awareness that of course belongs to the implicit narrator." -- p. 37

 ..... skip around from here....

Chapter III
Dual Religiosity


Chthonic and Olympian Gods

1


2

3

The Great Mother

1


2


3


4


5

6


7


8


9


10


11

The Origin and Gods of Olympos

1


2


Fate and Free Will

1


2



3



4



5



Delusion

1



2

3


4


Religious Duplicity

Many suggest -- Greeks and Homeric point of view: the Olympian gods and the patriarchal world order triumphed over Mother Earth, matriarchal world order, fertility cults -- but author suggests this is far from the case. In fact, there remained many religious festivals directed at the divinities of the underworld, the chthonic.

"It is not possible to maintain a sharp distinction between the upper Olympian and the lower chthonic world of gods and demons (daimones) [this might be first time author uses this word; not sure.] For example, Demeter [fertility god) lives on Olympos, while Zeus can be worshipped under the name of the Zeus of the underworld (Chthonios)."

The tyrant Peisistratos seems to come up in conversation a lot in this book: apparently "the mysteries in honor of Demeter and Dionysos were integrated by Peisistratos into the Athenian state. There were four annual festivals in honor of Dionysos, including the great Dionysian festival in which the tragedy competitions were held."

Strife (eris) vs love (eros).
Chapter IV
Athene and the Apple of Discord -- on Eros, Eris, and Metis 


Eros and eris


Prehistory

1



2

3

Division and Unification

1


2

Begins with Hesiod, and the Theogeny.

3


Athene -- Goddess of metis

1

Why Athene gets special attention:
  • she is Odysseus' protectress
  • she helps Telemachus to mature
  • she is behind Penelope's skill at weaving and deceiving the suitors
It appears the Iliad is Achilles; and, in The Odyssey is as much Athene as Odysseus.

Again, the Iliad may be Achilles, but it is the passing of the torch from Achilles (heroic age) to Odysseus (discursive age). 
 
2

3


4


5

6

7

8
Chapter V: The Telemachy

Athene's intervention in the passivity of Telemachus (much like the brooding Hamlet) is the theme of the first four books of the Odyssey, which have often been called the Telemachy. (This make me think of the first five books of Moses being called the Torah -- one wonders.)


The Maternal Bond

1

Chapter VI: Oydsseus

Chapter VII: The Wanderings

Chapter VIII: The Trials of Homecoming

Chapter IX: The Homeric Utopia

PART TWO: Socrates

Chapter X: The Subjective and Reflective Breakthrough in Poetry and Philosophy 





Chapter XIV: The Life and Form of Tragedy

To the world of literature, greatest contribution from Athens: bringing the tragedy to perfection.

The Return of Myth --
Dithyramb and Genesis
1

Aeschylus returns to Homer, as does Socrates.

"Whereas Homer's use of myth was to convert aristocratic and heroic ideals into peaceful ideals, the myth redivivus (through the tragedians) was to formulate a new set of rules for democratic citizens of Athens."

Prior to the three tragedians, others had used myth in a limited way: Hesiod, Archilochus, Solon, Semonides, Mimnermus, Sappho.

2

"It seems to be beyond doubt that Dionysos and tragedy are inextricably linked."

(Hermes was the second youngest of Zeus' progeny; Dionysos was the youngest.) 

Competitions in tragedy in Athens were held in his honor. But it is difficult to explain the connection AND why Dionysos never appears in any of the tragedies.

The author provides a possible connection; he notes that like all other gods, Dionysos appears in different forms -- depending on the function attributed to him (this is really well known for Athene).

Comedies: hallmark -- phallic songs.

In contrast to the phallic songs, there were four other types of songs:
  • hymn: prayers to the gods
  • lament: a contrasting one to hymns; passionate grief or sorrow
  • paeans: enthusiastic praise to the gods
  • dithyramb: a hymn devoted to Dionysos. "Dealing," Platos says in The Laws, "if I am not mistaken, with the birth of Dionysos."
The Bacchae is the only extant tragedy about Dionysos and his distinctive features; has the by-name of Dithyrambos in view of the myth that he was born twice; author relates that myth.

Page 331: the connection between the Dionysian intoxication, the tyrant Peisistratos, the birth song and choral form connected with development of the tragedy.

3

"While the basic form of tragedy developed from the Dionysian dithyramb, its content derives from myth, especially as it is known in Homer. Aristotle lived around 150 years after the rise of tragedy, which is why his description is encumbered with the same uncertainty that surrounded the rise of the epic." The author then gives Aristotle's explanation for rise of tragedy.

"Aristotle says that the Dorians in the Peloponnesus claimed to be the originators of tragedy, referring to the fact that the word "comedian" comes from the word for outlying hamlets (komai, which the Athenians called demes), where such figures used to wander about."

In Athens, tradition has it that the first named tragedian Thespis won a prize for a tragedy around 534 BC under the tyrant Peisistratos.

4

The author discusses Nietzsche: "Nietzsche assigns the origins of the tragedy to the Dionysian dithyrambs and the orgiastic life he imagines existed in connection with it."

Dramaturgy

1

The author proposes the following hypothesis on the development of tragedy: in the dithramb's original encomium of Dionysos, his life and deeds are recounted by the chorus leader in an exchange of song and dance with the chorus. In the middle of the 7th century BC, the chorus leader began to fill in his role in dialogue with the chorus and developed into the first actor. A dramatic space for action arose, where a single myth was to condense the sequence of events.

Aristotle confirms: says Aeschylus went from one to two actors. Sophocles introduced the third. At the same time, the chorus recedes ever more into the background as the spokesman for the poet.

Parallel to this, the formal structure of tragedy -- perhaps deriving from the ritual sequence (dromenon) in the dithyramb -- was formed by a prologue, the chorus' entrance song (parados), the plot-driven episodes in which the actors appear, the chorus' song from the orchestra (stasima) and the closing song (exodus). In addition comes the construction of the stage, the introduction of the scenery, a hoist for the deus ex machina -- in short, the whole theatrical apparatus that appears in later theater but was formed already in Greek tragedy -- not forgetting comedy.

2

Tragedy most likely means "goat song," derived from the word tragos, goat, though the reason for this is unclear. The author then gives several possible explanations.

3

Discusses the audience.

Tragedy's Athens
1

Regardless of the roots and earliest forms of tragedy, the decisive thing is that it is only known from Athens.

Again, the turning point in Athenian history: crushing the Persian fleet in 480 BC -- against all odds.

2

Discusses the necessary shifts in the minds of the Athenians.

Tragedy According to Aristotle

1

Aristotle used tragedy as a paradigm.

2

Even Homer and Hesiod spoke of the power of the fable or poetry over the listener.

3

Common to these tragedies, which developed according to moral necessity, is their telos: to describe human suffering, pathos. For without pathos, the audience cannot experience what is gripping about the mimesis in the play, as the characters elicit "pity (eleos) and fear (phobos) in their fateful deeds wherewith to accomplish [the play's] katharsis of such emotions."

4

5

6





Chapter XV: Aeschylus

The Poet From Eleusis
(about 11 miles northwest of center of Athens)
1
"In my analysis of the works of Aeschylus, my conclusion that Homer did not have or did not use the same knowledge [as Aeschylus] is based on the fact that he [Aeschylus?] conceived his works in the enlightened region of Ionia with a view to establishing a patriarchal form of government -- by repressing fertility cults such as that of Demeter.

2

The family of Aeschylus belonged to the cult surrounding the Mysteries. From wiki:
The Eleusinian Mysteries were initiations held every year for the cult of Demeter and Persephone based at Eleusis in ancient Greece. They are the "most famous of the secret religious rites of ancient Greece".
It is thought that their basis was an old agrarian cult which probably goes back to the Mycenean period (c. 1600 – 1100 BC) and it is believed that the cult of Demeter was established in 1500 BC.
The mysteries represented the myth of the abduction of Persephone from her mother Demeter by the king of the underworld Hades, in a cycle with three phases, the "descent" (loss), the "search" and the "ascent", with the main theme the "ascent" of Persephone and the reunion with her mother.
It was a major festival during the Hellenic era, and later spread to Rome. The name of the town, Eleusís, seems to be Pre-Greek and it is probably a counterpart with Elysium and the goddess Eileithyia.
3

Aeschylus probably grew up during a period when tyranny was declining and democracy was developing.

The Persians: the oldest extant tragedy, 472 BC.

At one time The Suppliant Maidens was thought to be older due to dominance of chorus. A second actor had not yet been developed by this time.

4

Important source for Aeschylus: Aristophanes' comedy The Frogs.

The Trilogy as Dramatic Necessity
1

2

The Persians
1


2

3


Seven Against Thebes
1

Aristophanes in The Frogs says The Persians and Seven Against Thebes were written in praise of Ares.  

2

3

4

The Suppliant Maidens
1

The flight of the Danaids, 50 young girls, from their country on the Nile to Argos.

2

3

The Fire-Bringer -- Prometheus Bound
1
Of all his plays, the most uncertainty surrounds this play.

2

3

4
The Oresteia
Metaphorical Paraphrase
1

458 BC: about 20 years after the Greek victory over the Persian

Written a few years before his death

"The tyrannical violation of the gods through arrogance is maintained as the curse, the guilt, the daimon or alastor, as it is also called, of the Atreid family.

"This guilt is ultimately only resolved in a development of consciousness, in which the primordial, death-bound world of blood revenge in mother cults is replaced by the paternal rule of the Olympian gods. Aeschylus takes this theme, consisting of the opposition between female and male, up through the constitution of Athenian democracy linked to the Areopagus Council.

2

Zeus Teleios
1


2



3

4


5

6

Suffering and Learning
1

The Agamemnon.

2


Hubris -- The Sure Road to Perdition
1

2


 

4

5

6

7

Choice and Sacrifice

1

2

3

4

Klytemnestra

1

2

3

4

5

6


Helen -- the dialectic between eros and eris
1


2


3

4

The Untrustworthy Seer 


The Matricide
1


2


3

4

5

6

The lex talionis of Blood Vengeance

1

2

3

The Principle of Father Power

1


2


3

4

5

6

7

8

9 

 
Chapter XVI: Sophocles

Sophocles: 496 - 406 BC -- about 16 years old when Athenians defeated the Persians; 90 years old
Metaphysical Indeterminacy
1
2
Known to posterity for having introduced a third actor in the dramatic repertoire.
But, more importantly, he abandoned the trilogy.
The third actor: a material shift in psychological analysis -- the actors now function as a mirror to each other.
Aeschylus needed the trilogy to describe the gods' diplay of power in a family and its generations.
3
Sophocles makes no use of inherited (blood) guilt; the true scene of the tragic consequently moves to the individual, who is placed at the center of the tragedy.
4
5
6
7
The daimon of the Tragic Hero
1
2
Ajax -- The Steadfast Tragic Hero
1
2
3
4
Antigone -- The Tragic Heroine
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
Oedipus the King -- Riddle and Prehistory
1
2
3
4
The Riddle Solver
1
2
3
4
Kreon -- The Pragmatic Politician
 Wife- -- Mother
1
2
3
Becoming Your Own Self
1
2
3
4
Oedipus at Colonus -- A Gift to Mankind
1
2
Guilt-Free and Sacred
1
2
The Tempters
1
2
3
Apotheosis
1
2
3
Philoktetes-- A Moral Mobilization Tract
1
2
3
The Wound, the Bow, and the Weapon of the Tongue
1
2
3
4
5
 

Chapter XVII: Euripides
  

Poet of Crisis
1
From above:
Euripedes won very few prizes (as opposed to Aeschylus and Sophocles); a rebel; "his main characters display hitherto unseen passions, and dramatically peripheral or useless figures such as peasants appear on stage and are credited with a noble quality that the traditional heroic types lack in their arrogance.
In addition, the gods seem to be deranged and Fate irresistible and unavoidable, while love leads to destruction. Women seem to be hated and men pathetic in their oppression." -- p. 456, Zeruneith. Iphigenia at Aulis; Electra; Orestes; Iphigenia at Taurus; Medea; Hippolytos; The Bacchae
It sounds like with Euripides we are moving from men believing that gods rule men's destiny, to a tragedian who believes the gods play a minimal, if any, role. "Man, not the gods, is made into the object of everything...." -- p. 461, Zeruneith.

Odysseus' Cynicism

Iphigenia at Aulis -- The Sacrifice

Elektra -- The Matricide

Orestes -- The Erinyes of Conscience

Iphigenia at Taurus -- The Reconciliation

Medea -- Uncontrolled Passion

Hippolytos -- Sexual Purism

The Bacchae -- A Vision

The End of Tragedy

The author notes that is is surprising that only these three great dramatists have survived for posterity.

Life span of tragedy: 65 years, dating back to The Persians and ending with Oedipus at Colonus and The Bacchae.

2

3
Tragedy disappears; fades away. Philosophy steps in to fill the void.  


Chapter XVIII: Socrates

The Iliad

The basic story:

The contest, Judgment of Paris.

Helen.

Menelaus.

Agamemnon.

Sacrifice of Agamemnon's daughter.

King of Troy.

Sons of the king of Troy.

The order of battle (key warriors):

Trojan:
  • King Priam
  • two sons of note: Hektor, Paris
  • Paris: kills Achilles, but with no honor/distinction for Paris;
  • Hektor: kills Patroclus, Achille's close buddy; ultimately killed by Achilles
  • Aeneas: one of the few Trojan survivors; escapes and founds Rome.
Greek:
  • Achilles, killed by Prince Paris, but with no honor/distinction
  • Neoptolemus (Pyrrhus), Achille's son: kills King Priam  
  • Philoctetes: kills Paris
  • Diomedes: wounded in foot by Paris
  • Patroclus: close buddy of Achilles; killed by Hektor
  • alternate spelling of Odysseus: Odusseus.
  • nine volunteer to fight Hektor,  book VIII, line 260, including,
    • the sons of Atreus, Agamemnon and Menelaus; Ajax the Greater, Ajax the Lesser, Diomedes, Idomeneus, his squire, Merionès; Eurypylos (son of Evæmone); and Teucer, the ninth one named; (one of my sources said Odysseus was one of the nine, but that appears incorrect)
    • the Greeks wanted Agamemnon, Diomedes, or Ajax the Greater
    • by lot, Ajax (Aias) the Greater won the right to fight Hektor 
    • Ajax winning the duel but Apollo intervened, saving Hektor; Hektor gave Ajax his sword; Ajax later killed himself with that sword
    • ultimately killed by Achilles
Back stories:

Iliad.

Achilles killed by Prince Paris. Philoktetes kills Prince Paris.

Torch passes from "heroic" / Achilles to "discursive" / Odysseus.
Discursive: consciousness; thought and action separate.
During "heroic" age, action and thought one and the same.
Separating thought and action, huge jump in human thought process.
E.g., if dogs think, then for a dog, action = thought; they occur simultaneously.
Humans: when acting rationally, thought precedes action.

Coincidentally, with the fall of Troy, the end of the Bronze Age.

After Achilles, top three Greek warriors:
Odysseus, Diomedes, and XXXXXXX

Might one consider "the Wooden Horse" a metonym for strategic thinking? "To solve this problem, we need a "wooden horse.""



*****************************
Geneaology

Zeus / Athene

Hermes

Odysseus: the grandson of the god Hermes;

Homer: the grandson of Odysseus

Socrates: felt himself to be an "Odysseus."

****************************
Homer
Invented Mount Olympus and the gods, or at least "synthesized" the folk myths.

**********************
Diomedes

From this link.

Diomedes:
  • a hero in Greek mythology for role in Trojan War
  • Iliad: Achilles at the top warrior, but the next three:
  • Ajax the Great; Agamemnon; and Diomedes
  • these three: the Aecheans want one of these three to fight Hector out of nine volunteers (included Odysseus and Ajax the Lesser)
  • Argos
  • maternal grandfather: Adrastus -- legendary king of Argos during the wars of the Seven Against Thebes
  • parents: Tydeus (Aetolian) and Deipyle (Argive)
  • Diomedes: becomes king of Argos following his maternal grandfather, Adrastus
  • founded ten Italian cities
  • after his death, worshipped as a god by both Greeks and Romans
**********************************
Peisistratos

Peisistratos (Greek: Πεισίστρατος; died 528/7 BC), latinised Pisistratus, the son of Hippocrates, was a ruler of ancient Athens during most of the period between 561 and 527 BC. Link here.
His legacy lies primarily in his instituting the Panathenaic Games, historically assigned the date of 566 BC, and the consequent first attempt at producing a definitive version of the Homeric epics.
Peisistratos' championing of the lower class of Athens, the Hyperakrioi, is an early example of populism.
While in power, Peisistratos did not hesitate to confront the aristocracy, and he greatly reduced their privileges, confiscated their lands and gave them to the poor and funded many religious and artistic programs. He did so with the goal of improving the economy and spreading the wealth more equally among the Athenians.

***************************************
Three Women Cousins: Helen of Troy; Penelope, and Klytemnestra

The women:
  • half-sisters:
    • Helen: daughter of Zeus and Leda
    • Klytemnestra: daughter of Tyndareus and Leda, King and Queen of Sparta
  • cousin:
    • Penelope: cousin of Helen and Klytemnestra
Klytemnestra: suitors how up in mass; Odysseus suggests to her father that he require suitors to pledge allegiance to her husband if ever attacked. As a reward for that advice, Odysseus asked for/and received Penelope as his wife. Penelope was daughter of Ikarios, brother of King Tyndareios.

The marriages:
  • Klytemnestra marries Agamemnon
  • Helen marries Menelaus
  • Penelope marries Odyssesus
Deity:
  • Klytemnestra: daughter of a God (Zeus)
  • Odysseus: traces ancestry to Hermes
Trojan War
  • strife brought to world by Zeus; reason not well stated
  • may have had to do with impressing his daughter Helen
  • be that as it may:
Zeus wanted to marry the sea nymph Thetis, but seer says daughter of Thetis will be greater than the father.

Therefore, Zeus won't marry Thetis. Rather Thetis marries King Peleus: son Achilles.

Thetis and King Peleus: all gods invited to wedding except Eris, goddess of strife; as revenge, rolls apple, "to the fairest" among Athene, Hera, and Aphrodite. Strife immediately breaks out. Zeus won't make decision. Passes the buck to Paris, son of King Priam, Troy. Each promise him wealth and power, but Aphrodite promises him the married Helen.

So, therefore we have most of the main characters.

Around all this, Homer:
  • invents Mount Olympus and all the gods
  • the story of the Trojan War
  • the myth of discursiveness
  • a great war story 


And so it begins.